Bird feeding is often a process of trial and error.
Many of us start by thinking it's simple: buy a bag of seeds, hang it up, and wait for the magic. But without the right knowledge, it’s easy to make mistakes that create mess, waste money, or even harm the birds.
A golden rule to live by is simple: unless you are able and willing to properly maintain the feeders, it’s better not to put them out at all.
Based on the hard-earned lessons from the birding community, here is a guide to seeds, safety, and smart setups to save you the trouble of learning the hard way.
1. The Seed Mistake: Stop Feeding the Squirrels
Many beginners start with basic "wild bird seed blends" from grocery stores. However, experienced birders quickly notice a pattern: birds often pick through the mix, eating what they like and flicking the rest onto the ground.
The culprits are usually cracked corn and millet. Most backyard birds ignore them, but squirrels love them. By using cheap blends with fillers, you are essentially creating a mess that invites rodents.
- The Fix: Switch from blends to 100% Black Oil Sunflower Seeds. Buying in bulk at hardware stores is often a great value.
- The Result: Less mess and less waste since most birds enjoy them. Plus, it attracts a wide variety of colorful birds without leaving leftovers for the squirrels.
2. Suet Strategy: Go Corn-Free
When it comes to suet, ingredients matter. Just like with loose seeds, if a suet cake has corn fillers, the birds will often flick the corn out onto the ground.
-
The Fix: Look for suet cakes that are peanut-based and explicitly corn-free. This simple switch keeps the ground cleaner and keeps the suet-eating birds much happier.
3. The "Diva" Diners: Mealworms vs. Larvae
For those feeding insect-loving birds like Bluebirds and Wrens, budget is often a concern. Dried soldier fly larvae are a cheaper alternative to dried mealworms, but be warned: birds can be picky eaters.
Transitioning from mealworms to larvae might take time. Birds may refuse the new food for a week or more.
-
The Advice: Patience pays off. If the budget dictates a switch, stick with it. Eventually, the birds will adapt to the soldier fly larvae, but don't be discouraged by their initial reluctance.
4. A Crucial Warning: Baby Bird Safety
This is a critical safety tip that often goes overlooked. Dried worms can be dangerous during breeding season.
Baby birds get their hydration second-hand through the insects their parents feed them. Dried worms are extremely dry and can lead to dehydration in the nestlings.
-
The Rule: During the summer breeding season, it is safer to hold off on dried worms. Instead, offer live mealworms (supplemented with vitamins and minerals) or pause worm feeding entirely until the babies have fledged.
5. Hummingbird Safety: Cleanliness is Key
Hummingbird feeders are a beautiful addition to any garden, but they come with strict responsibility. They must be emptied and disinfected at least weekly in the summer, and even more often in hot or humid areas.
-
The Danger: If not cleaned regularly, sugar water can get overrun with a toxic fungus. This fungus can cause a hummingbird’s tongue to swell, making it impossible for them to retract it, leading to starvation.
-
The Fix: Opt for a smaller feeder (e.g., four ounces). This forces frequent refills and cleaning cycles, preventing waste and ensuring the nectar is always fresh and safe.
The Ultimate Setup Recommendations
Based on these community insights, here is a recommended setup for a tidy, safe, and bird-friendly backyard:
-
One Seed Feeder: Filled strictly with Black Oil Sunflower Seeds.
-
One Suet Feeder: Peanut-based, corn-free.
-
One Smart Camera Feeder: Filled with dried or live mealworms. (Since squirrels generally dislike worms, this prevents them from chewing on expensive plastic smart feeders!)
-
Hummingbird Feeder: Only deployed when you can commit to strict cleaning schedules.
Bird feeding is a joy, but doing it right ensures it remains a joy for the birds, too.
References & Credits: This guide was curated based on real user experiences and discussions from the r/birds community on Reddit. We love seeing birders share their authentic tips and "trial and error" stories to help the whole flock grow. [Read the original discussion on Reddit here]